The Problem with YouTube Rewind!

  • Published on Dec 12, 2018
  • A look into RU-clip Rewind from someone who was in it. Is this what you wanted?
    RU-clip Rewind 2011:
    RU-clip Rewind 2012:
    RU-clip Rewind 2013:
    RU-clip Rewind 2014:
    RU-clip Rewind 2015:
    RU-clip Rewind 2016:
    RU-clip Rewind 2017:
    RU-clip Rewind 2018:
    MKBHD Merch:
    Video Gear I use:
    Tech I'm using right now:
    Intro Track: Half of the Way by Vulfpeck
  • Science & TechnologyScience & Technology

Comments • 37 813

  • PoluX
    PoluX 3 hours ago

    All the comments MUST HAVE THE LETTERS m, a and r.

  • Lightning Strike
    Lightning Strike 9 hours ago

    i was surprised this video didn't got taken down due to inappropriate content for youtube

  • Alex Games
    Alex Games 11 hours ago

    The reason small creators are

  • Alejandro Patino
    Alejandro Patino Day ago +1

    Now I’m suddenly craving some *m a r k a s s b r o w n i e s*

  • Frank Of the filth

    Markass Brownie

  • Zuhair Khan
    Zuhair Khan 2 days ago +1

    *_M A R K A S S B R O W N L E E_*

  • Hip Hop Kandy Shop
    Hip Hop Kandy Shop 2 days ago

    lol I literally just cried watching that 2018 rewind video

  • Zander's Universe
    Zander's Universe 2 days ago

    When RU-clip wants the rewind to be ad-friendly...
    *M A R K A S S B R O W N L E E*

  • Feza Gaming
    Feza Gaming 2 days ago

    Is this what you wanted? :/

  • Seth Brillinger
    Seth Brillinger 3 days ago

    mark ass brownie

  • ItsKaiya •
    ItsKaiya • 3 days ago

    why is everyone talking about mostly

    mark A** brownlee? .-.

  • Bat Max 444 Bat
    Bat Max 444 Bat 3 days ago

    Mark ass browne

  • classic bro
    classic bro 5 days ago

    Markass brownlee

  • Theo Kitsberg
    Theo Kitsberg 6 days ago +2

    Rewind looks at biggest RU-cliprs. Pewdiepie: hold my beer.
    RU-clip: NO

  • aashroughh
    aashroughh 6 days ago

    surpirised he mentioned ksi vs logan

  • md hasan
    md hasan 6 days ago

    Why RU-clip hates pewdiepie so much!!!???

  • Curiosity
    Curiosity 6 days ago +10

    RU-clip: what do you want in the rewind?
    People: Pewdiepi-
    RU-clip: *Im going to stop you right there*

  • Austin Chase
    Austin Chase 7 days ago +3

    You know what... Mark ass browny awnser this .*iNhAlEs* WHERE WAS STAN LEE IN REWIND 2018 HUH HUH?

  • ryan nuralif
    ryan nuralif 7 days ago

    Markass brownie

    MILF BOI 8 days ago

    RU-clip: Hippity hoppity 2019 no more Mark-Ass Brownie.

  • jay masters
    jay masters 9 days ago +2

    the problem with it is because it was extremely cringy and pushed at least 2 very controversial political ideologies.

  • Uchiha Trump
    Uchiha Trump 9 days ago

    Markass Brownie.....

  • The Pleb
    The Pleb 9 days ago

    Ahhhhhh that's hot

  • Cool Boi05
    Cool Boi05 10 days ago +1

    FortNite and this guy

  • Maraki Asrat
    Maraki Asrat 10 days ago

    5:15 RYAN!!!???

  • It'sDogePlayz
    It'sDogePlayz 11 days ago +1

    I wonder how RU-clip rewind 2019 will be

    • OskR
      OskR 9 days ago +1

      I don't wanna know

  • WarriorboyG
    WarriorboyG 12 days ago


  • Anthony 1220
    Anthony 1220 12 days ago

    Fortnite and markass brownie

  • Max Nieves
    Max Nieves 14 days ago

    MARKASS Brownlee

  • Woof
    Woof 15 days ago +1

    Why the hell is everyone hearing Markass Brownie while I hear Marques Brownlee?

  • Jodi Brunner
    Jodi Brunner 16 days ago +2

    you could have just made a 1 second video saying. “Everything”
    (Based on the title)

  • Antonin Nabor
    Antonin Nabor 19 days ago

    Biggest creators, are you kidding me, where the heck is pewdiepie

  • Lindsay Fisher
    Lindsay Fisher 22 days ago

    Maybe they should stop pushing liberal agendas down everyone’s throats?

  • Lindsay Fisher
    Lindsay Fisher 22 days ago

    U gay

  • Valeria Vagapova
    Valeria Vagapova 23 days ago +1

    Thanks so much for explaining actually! I was completely lost when I watched that rewind, I didn't understand what the hell the flying bus was all about (I heard that Fortnite was a game but obviously never played it) and it just was totally lost on me. And you're right, everything was happening so fast that it never ended up making much sense.

  • Marvil Romero Santos
    Marvil Romero Santos 25 days ago

    MarkAss Brownie😂😂

  • madscientist 666
    madscientist 666 25 days ago

    RU-clip rewind not just lot of fortnite.

    But also lot of soyboy, cringey sjw, overemotional etc. What a world of shit today

  • J Terry TV
    J Terry TV 27 days ago +2

    Stars in YTRewind 2018

    Makes a rant about why it was cringe

    Seems legit.

  • Shalfoshizzle
    Shalfoshizzle 27 days ago

    Did youtube pay these youtubers to be in the video?

  • jameswalker199
    jameswalker199 27 days ago

    I heard people were actually liking Baby to bump rewind down even further.

  • Han Jang
    Han Jang 28 days ago

    ha unbox therapy has 14 million subs

  • phlora
    phlora 29 days ago

    Markass Brownlee

  • F r e i d a
    F r e i d a Month ago +1

    One of the things that ruined it was too much fortnite. Everytime I saw fortnite I wanted to die. For real.

      MJN SEIFER 27 days ago +1

      Out of curiosity, would it have been better for you if the Fortnite references were more spaced out and/or if there had been something else going on at the same time as more of them?
      Like, if they had decided "We're having several Fortnite references in this Rewind, no arguments." would either or both of the above had made this fact more forgivable?

  • PewDiePie a
    PewDiePie a Month ago

    I'm late,so I can't say a meme about Mark ass Brownie.

  • David Slokar
    David Slokar Month ago

    I saw you on the empire team

  • firestonegraywolf
    firestonegraywolf Month ago

    you need a haircut

  • maGoH Labramonte
    maGoH Labramonte Month ago +2

    Stand Name: *[M a r k A S S B r o w n i e]*
    Stand User: Will Smith
    Araki needs to make this canon.

  • white dragon
    white dragon Month ago +5

    Real reason for dislikes is not including PewDiePie

  • Velo C. Raptor
    Velo C. Raptor Month ago +3

    Dont agree completely?
    I mean if its for advertiser, what the hell is Ninja doing there?

  • ACoustaDC
    ACoustaDC Month ago

    Want it fixed, let Casey edit it... like his "do what you can't" video.

  • Minzou Youn
    Minzou Youn Month ago

    Markass Brownie

  • Kinetic
    Kinetic Month ago +1

    M A R K A S S B R O W N I E

  • John P.
    John P. Month ago

    wearing black and having black in the background doesn’t suit you. this vid is so dim i had to turn up my screen brightness to maximum 🔆🔆🔆🔆🔆

    • Kris Paul
      Kris Paul Month ago

      So.... he should change his background rather than you increase your brightness... sounds reasonable

  • AndrzejAviation
    AndrzejAviation Month ago

    Is this what you wanted?

  • AceGaming64
    AceGaming64 Month ago

    everything is the problem

  • MICOLE WHYTE #Oneplus6T

    The good old RU-clip days was from 2007-2013

    • Four Knocks
      Four Knocks 17 days ago


      MJN SEIFER 26 days ago

      I agree about the comments being bad, but I disagree on the whole talentless people thing - people just like different RU-cliprs, and are entertained by them. I respect your opinion though, it's just that the years I mentioned were when I started appreciating the RU-clipr side of things, so they are the golden years for me.

    • MICOLE WHYTE #Oneplus6T
      MICOLE WHYTE #Oneplus6T 27 days ago

      @MJN SEIFER RU-clip is not as good as it used to be too many trolls too many idiots on RU-clip too many children one comment can start a war I the comment section too much fanboyism too many talentless people with millions of subscribers like superwoman Jenna marbles PewDiePie and a whole bunch of other RU-cliprs. RU-clip was better and the 2007- 2013

      MJN SEIFER 27 days ago

      For me it's around 2013 to the present day. It's just that, that's where I started to really see what variety RU-clip had, and I started caring more about the RU-clipr side of things. I honestly think RU-clip is still good, if we focus on creating rather than what we don't like about it (and yes, I know there are some "broken" aspects to RU-clip, but hopefully they'll get better.)

    • Tom Murphy
      Tom Murphy Month ago

      2015 and 2016 were decent. just before the mad censorship

  • Daniel Remix
    Daniel Remix Month ago

    I don't think his opinion exactly matches the majority of others. Clumping stuff in wasn't the problem, it was the way they presented. Rewind is supposed to be fun, entertaining, and see the most popular stuff. No one wants to hear about "Oh look at how cool this gender" "Oh congrats to my race, we made strives" or "Melting lipsticks". Those are not fun nor entertaining subjects and to add controversial crappy views to up others at a low level was just not respectable. Most of the stuff was forced as well even though they motto was it is the viewers choice.

      MJN SEIFER 27 days ago

      I feel that the Rewind didn't know exactly what it wanted to be, and "Clumping stuff in" had something to do with it, but part of it does have to do with what you're saying. I feel they tried too hard to make it different things, and (no disrespect to it, as some of it was the RU-cliprs thanking their fans) they didn't need the serious talking part in the main Rewind.
      It's good to give thanks and that, and to show support for different people, but like you say, the Rewinds should be fun. They are an entertaining nostalgia trip of RU-clip of that year, and that is what they should be presented as.

  • Nick Wolf
    Nick Wolf Month ago

    Markass Brownie

  • เด็กชายณฐกร กังวาล

    ForkKnife and Marcunt Browny

  • I_Main_IQ_ 69
    I_Main_IQ_ 69 Month ago

    Is this what you wanted?

  • DJRiptide BackUps
    DJRiptide BackUps Month ago

    aawwwwawwaAAW das hot

  • Loweduckwing
    Loweduckwing Month ago

    That’s hot

  • DebzLife
    DebzLife Month ago +7

    ☑🍑 🌰

    *_MarkAss Brownie._*

  • K Hearts
    K Hearts Month ago +1

    Mark ass brownie

  • Ali Ali
    Ali Ali Month ago

    You're markass braiwni

  • TheAdekrijger
    TheAdekrijger Month ago

    Markass brownie!!!!

  • Ash Oleson
    Ash Oleson Month ago +1

    Will Smith: 8:33

  • SabotagedGaming YT
    SabotagedGaming YT Month ago

    Markass vrownlee

  • Jordan van der Walt
    Jordan van der Walt Month ago +1

    I just want to take a buzzer and cut the grass in the background

  • SharkHark
    SharkHark Month ago

    So. Finally a youtube in RU-clip Rewind that is honest.

  • Willam Millar
    Willam Millar Month ago


  • Gemi Plays
    Gemi Plays Month ago

    What am i doing here lol

  • BetaBeast
    BetaBeast Month ago

    Ok markass brownie

  • Beqa Mikautadze
    Beqa Mikautadze Month ago +1

    *RU-clip headquarters
    Boss:What shuld we add this year?
    Guy: so this year we should do something different something original that will change the perspective of the rewind
    Boss: and what's that?
    Guy:we must add VINERS!!

  • MoRpH
    MoRpH Month ago

    will smith ruined marques. fuck you will smith. I fuckin hate will smith. such a bitch

  • Flawless Fatality
    Flawless Fatality Month ago

    Anything with fortnite involved is a bad idea waiting to happen

  • Libru_The_Kazekage
    Libru_The_Kazekage Month ago

    How does it fell to have Will Smith call you *mARkaSs bROwNliE*

  • The Spider Plays
    The Spider Plays Month ago


  • anime-manga -movies Man

    Why will smith want fortnite abd marq ASS brownlee!?

  • ExoAssassin
    ExoAssassin Month ago

    Correct me if I’m wrong but has pewdiepie ever been featured in rewind

  • Saif Iqbal
    Saif Iqbal Month ago +1

    Yaaaaaah, It’s rewind time!

    Nah iF I cOnTrOl rEwInD I wOuLd wAnT FOOOTTNIGHTTT

    Some mark assed brownies!


    How RU-clip Knows ItsFunneh Clothes and Nail Colour?

  • Владимир Путин

    Markass Brownlee

  • San The Man
    San The Man Month ago

    MarkASS Brownlee

  • Thisistrueart
    Thisistrueart Month ago

    I'm getting flashbacks to RU-clip Rewind please help me I'm going inside

  • GoldSphere / Spherey
    GoldSphere / Spherey Month ago +1

    people say rewind is cringe, thats the problem

  • k
    k Month ago

    *Cough cough*

  • Su Tart’s son
    Su Tart’s son Month ago +1

    Markass brown-league.

  • False Heaven
    False Heaven Month ago

    Mark ass browney

  • Young Colgate
    Young Colgate Month ago +3

    Technically, 2010 had a rewind too.

  • товарищ мартин

    Mark 'dat' ass Brownlee

  • Stay Chill
    Stay Chill Month ago


  • Andrej Z
    Andrej Z Month ago

    Very well said.

  • hiitoast242
    hiitoast242 Month ago +1

    Poor Marques,was called markass brownie,and is in the worst rewind

  • Dorian Vrbančić
    Dorian Vrbančić Month ago

    7:26 video cuted down and display on my phone turned of....
    What the fu**

  • VoidedMirror
    VoidedMirror Month ago

    I featured a majority of people I don't subscribe to or care about. 🤷🏻‍♂️

  • ThelittleAma
    ThelittleAma Month ago

    Congratulations, now you won't get featured in Rewind 2019 👏

  • Neo Fury
    Neo Fury Month ago +6

    MKBHD : *Criticizes RU-clip for making and using rewind as a business tool *
    RU-clip: No more Rewind for you !

  • Player
    Player Month ago +4

    pewdiepie was not there so thats why we 9-year-olds planned to dislike it