YouTube's copyright system is broken

Share
Embed
  • Published on May 19, 2019
  • Warner Chappell have copyright claimed 25% of my content in 2 hours and there isn't much I can do about it.
    Warner Chappell's information for research
    UK twitter - twitter.com/warner_chappell
    US twitter - twitter.com/WarnerChappell
    Facebook - facebook.com/warnerchappellmusic/
    Instagram - instagram.com/warnerchappellmusic
    My Twitter: twitter.com/ThatMumboJumbo
  • GamingGaming

Comments • 17 374

  • Mumbo Jumbo
    Mumbo Jumbo  3 months ago +6904

    UPDATE (as taken from my twitter)

    Things are a bit muddy.
    - I do have written permission from the artist to use the claimed song.
    - However; the song uses a sample that has been picked up by Warners content ID bot. So I am being claimed for a sample, not the song.

    I'm still hoping we can resolve this.
    And take this as a lesson from me:
    Not only should you ensure you have complete rights to the music you are using for your videos, but also ensure that you ask about any samples that have been used. Otherwise you could end up in this situation (And you wouldn't want that).
    Will do a video on Tuesday explaining. I am taking a day off tomorrow!

    • Carol Pintilie
      Carol Pintilie Day ago

      basically fuck youtube's copyright system at the moment

    • Spencer Lloyd
      Spencer Lloyd Day ago

      Mumbo you are my favourite RU-clipr ever

    • Lt. Zero
      Lt. Zero 2 days ago

      Hypothetically, can you use the full song instead, since you have a written permission for it?

    • Cherry Dragon
      Cherry Dragon 2 days ago

      Or... youtube should get their fricking arses out of their chair and FIX THEIR DAMNED BROKEN PLATFORM!

    • Chili
      Chili 2 days ago

      Omg you cute

  • Cree price
    Cree price 31 minute ago

    FUCK THAT MAN! Seriously dude, your such a nice guy who is genuinely a creator on youtube! take it to court mumbo! Take it to court!

  • Kyler Withrow
    Kyler Withrow 6 hours ago

    Fuck RU-clip they don’t care

  • Renso Daniel Del Castillo Vega

    You should check the case of CNN Chile against LuisitoComunica

  • Random Memes Weekly
    Random Memes Weekly 7 hours ago

    FUCK WARNER CHAPPELL!

  • cycodude boi
    cycodude boi 7 hours ago

    Dear Mumbo Jumbo your video: RU-clip's copyright system is broken, contains air, this has been claimed by UMG for breathing similar air to the songwriters in our company

  • AshtonIsaiah Caldwell
    AshtonIsaiah Caldwell 8 hours ago

    This is also happening to JT from a guy named enes batur

  • boulderbash19700209
    boulderbash19700209 8 hours ago

    Still don't believe EU article 13 will kill the internet?

  • Muhammad Fadhilah
    Muhammad Fadhilah 9 hours ago

    and don't worry.. I've made a video too and they also tell that my own voice is their song... but it's not even a song.

  • Link The Fox
    Link The Fox 9 hours ago

    Put up a lawsuit with Warner Chapel

  • Muhammad Fadhilah
    Muhammad Fadhilah 9 hours ago

    where's your moustache?

  • The Rockstar Gamer
    The Rockstar Gamer 10 hours ago +1

    “Innocent until proven guilty”
    The entire globe:
    :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
    RU-clip:
    D:

  • Xealz
    Xealz 10 hours ago

    Kill those bastards

  • Kusarigama_ 15
    Kusarigama_ 15 12 hours ago

    #fixyoutubecopyright

  • Nice Shoes
    Nice Shoes 13 hours ago

    You look like jamie oliver

  • Kuba Czupyt
    Kuba Czupyt 13 hours ago

    A gaming channel called “Teo” had the exact same situation (same company, same deal with his outro music) about a week ago, he managed to have the claims removed.

  • :/
    :/ 16 hours ago

    Mumbo's Legal Borrowed Music: *Breathes*
    Warner Chapshit: *HIPPITY HOPPITY YOUR CONTENT IS NOW COPYRIGHTED*

  • -InfStudios-
    -InfStudios- 20 hours ago

    Just Realized Logdotzip Liked This.

  • The Savage Method
    The Savage Method 21 hour ago

    Most importantly this has been a growing problem with youtube. Over the last year or so I've seen many videos of my favorite channels face similar problems. The new algorithms used are hurting content creators and forcing censorship of different channels. On a side not Mumbo you really should have worn a stash I mean its kinda your thing. It was kinda disappointing you didnt at least wear a fake stash. I know this is a serious topic that effects your livelihood but by staying in character I believe that your important message would have reached even further. Just my honest opinion. Honestly I think its time someone replaced youtube and their new gestapo rules. On the flip side maybe its time to branch out a little to secure your much needed paycheck.

  • DaniloKING 2
    DaniloKING 2 Day ago +1

    Ok this is what I call communism

  • ComicalOrange
    ComicalOrange Day ago

    RU-clip needs several different HQ's, so this shit is easier to sort out.

  • Ignacio Sánchez

    Make a redstone contraption to reclaim the videos

  • Ali Razi
    Ali Razi Day ago

    We should all just boycott you tube until they fix this shit do u know if minecraft community gaming community and nine year old army just boycott youtube for a single week how much revenue they'll lose

  • Foxstrike Computing

    Don’t worry, my channel got taken down for someone Spanish getting into my account. I had to email them for months to get it back! Darn hackers!

  • LossGaming
    LossGaming Day ago

    Yeah sorry, I own this video now.

  • daneeko
    daneeko Day ago

    its absolutely fine for companies to have bots automatically copyright claim videos for the smallest reasons, and then not get punished for it

  • adds reclame
    adds reclame Day ago

    Make a company account and claim your own videos

  • PhilippeAquilaniAndre

    I agree one video of mine got Copyright claim even tho I USED COPYRIGHT FREE SONGS ON THAT DAMN VIDEO!!!

  • Mathu-Andrew Budge

    welp, i'm off to copyright claim all of warner bros videos.

  • PHOTON
    PHOTON Day ago +1

    talking about losing money....in his million-dollar penthouse.
    Though ya, still...fuck warner chappell

  • Luke Gabriel Balgan

    I can only imagine when the comment section gets copyright-claimed. Among the several millions of comments, perhaps billions even, the chance that no two comments are similar is basically 0. And if the whole 3 strikes you're out thing extends to taking down the account altogether, all accounts that currently exist are 100% screwed. Let's hope that doesn't happen.

  • Reidsplosion 214

    either UMG or Warner.

  • MulletEagle
    MulletEagle Day ago

    Wait,



    Where's your mustache?

  • JoshIsSarcastic
    JoshIsSarcastic Day ago

    This is what exactly what happened to Pyrocinical

  • Soup Bear
    Soup Bear Day ago

    The system is so broken, like the people that claim videos should actually show proof that they have the rights to claim a video, RU-clip should actually watch over these things since they can have bad outcomes for a channel but no RU-clip is just lazy

  • Bernie Sanders
    Bernie Sanders Day ago

    They should give copyright strikes to those who create false claims

  • Reazet
    Reazet 2 days ago

    RU-clip doesn't care about who made what, best example is famous musician TheFatRat. His music is being taken down for just being a free source. Silent clips can be taken down for music copyright violation and be happy that your channel is still up, I had a rdm video on a rdm channel. The channel is gone. With no influence you are fucked on RU-clip.

  • IsaacC 123
    IsaacC 123 2 days ago

    rip

  • Mariano Lucas
    Mariano Lucas 2 days ago

    I guess we must refer to them as Whiner Chappell, I mean, that's their real name right?

  • Redpoppy
    Redpoppy 2 days ago

    This is why Copyright law needs to be INNOCENT until proven guilty instead of what is currently the case where it is GUILTY until PROVEN innocent.

  • Ashonic
    Ashonic 2 days ago

    Wheres your mustache

  • Uranus InBanana
    Uranus InBanana 2 days ago

    the thing is if youtube fucks up and allows copyrighted material they could lose alot and i mean alot of money however i do agree that doing false DMCA should face reprecusion

  • Dylan Lasuandaqua
    Dylan Lasuandaqua 2 days ago

    Warner chappel should get sued. RU-cliprs need to band together and do something

  • Depression
    Depression 2 days ago

    This is why youtube will die one day

  • Random YouTube User
    Random YouTube User 2 days ago

    #JusticeForMumbo

  • Felipe Hindi
    Felipe Hindi 2 days ago

    This is not exceptional, just regular profit driven companies doing profit driven things.
    It would be so, so much better if content creators had their own platform somehow!

  • theunicornatihascome

    Just remove audio from your videos

  • Cherry Dragon
    Cherry Dragon 2 days ago

    Rest in peace mumbo.
    RU-clip is incredibly brutal for destroying people their jobs and lives just because a damn company claimed half your library of video's. Its total mayhem on how Bad youtube has gotten over few years

  • Hansen Edits
    Hansen Edits 2 days ago

    God dam you have a nice house

  • f4tornado
    f4tornado 2 days ago +1

    RU-clip is not going to care. RU-clip has a monopoly on individually produced video content, since all the viewers are there because all the creators are there because all the viewers are there. Therefore, they don't have to worry about what anyone thinks, because they can't leave.

    The only way I see this changing is if droves of youtubers decide to drop youtube and switch to another platform. then, youtube would lose a significant amount of revenue, and decide to change the system for their money back.

  • Gidster1
    Gidster1 2 days ago +1

    When a Minecraft youtuber starts talking about RU-clip issues that’s when you know the system’s seriously flawed

  • IDrovePastYourHouse -

    [comment has been deleted and claimed]

  • Schpinnerman
    Schpinnerman 2 days ago +1

    Someone should finally get a lawyer and sue someone for this bs

  • Dark Lusare
    Dark Lusare 2 days ago

    is this already solved? I thought this video was posted today, but it actually was three month ago, before I found the channel

  • I haven't showered in 6 weeks, but

    A thought, can you just remove the song (mute it) from your intro? Will that stop these leeches from sapping your revenue?

  • Dark Lusare
    Dark Lusare 2 days ago

    ok, I've seen this shit, but my fucking god!!
    RU-clip JUST WAKE UP! Company clearly abusing the copyright system NOW!! 400 videos claimed in 2 hours, that are at least 10-20 minutes long, they are just claiming everything left and right, knowing there will be NO CONSEQUENCES!!
    just do something about it! there are thousands tons of people who already said how to fix the system, by adding fine for false claim and etc.
    I don't even know why I'm writing this!. it won't even be read by anyone in youtube company, fuck I just really wanna this to stop, it really is absurd now.

  • HousedHorse
    HousedHorse 2 days ago

    You should join the RU-cliprs union: www.fairtube.info/en/

  • PatchyCat Gaming
    PatchyCat Gaming 2 days ago +1

    SUE THEM

  • Beños
    Beños 2 days ago

    why dont you claim the revenue yourself with a 2nd account?

  • Sandra Skender
    Sandra Skender 2 days ago

    *Warner chappel wants to know your location*

  • H Dawg Studios
    H Dawg Studios 2 days ago

    Are we not gonna talk about how we totally dislike bombed there channel

  • Zyriarch
    Zyriarch 2 days ago

    is there a way that all youtubers, or at least most of them, can go on strike?

  • Greg Dad
    Greg Dad 2 days ago

    jesus christ mumbo, you are surprisingly fit

  • Connor Gable
    Connor Gable 2 days ago

    So sorry, that sucks

  • Bestcool5
    Bestcool5 2 days ago

    This is mental

  • Elaine Francis
    Elaine Francis 2 days ago +1

    WHERE'S THE MOUSTACHE

  • Quack Nation
    Quack Nation 2 days ago

    Mumbo is in so much problem ;w; i hate RU-clip,RU-clip is bully!!

  • Quack Nation
    Quack Nation 2 days ago

    I think that RU-clip is being a bully,we should look for a new platform and with the help of our favorite creators,we should migrate to another platform

  • Sticks InStilts
    Sticks InStilts 2 days ago

    Forecast for the next few years, youtube goes under due to lack of good content, and twitch becomes the new youtube.

  • socrlax
    socrlax 2 days ago +2

    Fuck youtube, really... if there were a better platform, I would never use youtube again.

  • RoboFox
    RoboFox 2 days ago +2

    RU-clip in the old days:
    A fun job
    RU-clip now:
    A fun job that is 100% risky

    • fredy gump
      fredy gump Day ago +1

      Assuming RU-clip is a "secure" job in any sense of the word...is a big mistake!

  • Galantir Galadross
    Galantir Galadross 2 days ago

    This has been happening for years now, youtube content creators going on a bout copyrights problem on the platform.
    but NONE of them will leave the platform, NONE of them get together and form their own platform.
    No they all want to keep using the FREE platform youtube because it's easy.
    Please stop whining about copyright problems when you keep posting your videos on a platform known for copyright problems.

  • MNX
    MNX 2 days ago

    Damn what a room o.o

  • The Professional Idiots

    We can't even raid them because they have a flush 3x3 piston doors

  • Hazzard
    Hazzard 2 days ago

    I hope you got a lawyer