Watch a fly-through animation of Notre-Dame rebuilt with a reconstructed spire and glass roof

Share
Embed
  • Published on May 17, 2019
  • Miysis Studio has created an animation showing its vision of a rebuilt Notre-Dame that combines a reconstruction of Viollet-le-Duc spire with a modern glass roof.The Belgium visualisation studio created the movie to show how the cathedral, which was devastated by fire last month, could be rebuilt using modern and traditional materials.
    Read more on Dezeen: www.dezeen.com/?p=1359622
    WATCH NEXT: Lasers and drones are preserving world heritage sites - ru-clip.net/video/XOWiBStJJ04/video.html
    Subscribe to our RU-clip channel for the latest architecture and design movies: bit.ly/1tcULvh
    Like Dezeen on Facebook: dezeen/
    Follow Dezeen on Twitter: Dezeen/
    Follow us on Instagram: dezeen
    Check out our Pinterest: uk.pinterest.com/dezeen/
  • EntertainmentEntertainment

Comments • 67

  • Lukas Schällibaum
    Lukas Schällibaum Month ago

    It will be very hot there. Huuge glass area for the sun to heat up that thing

  • J.R. Productions
    J.R. Productions Month ago +1

    They NEED to do this!

  • Valentin Roesler
    Valentin Roesler 2 months ago

    If France wants to ruin Paris, go for it

  • tamiasthechipmunk
    tamiasthechipmunk 2 months ago

    How about restoring the visual appearance of the cathedral to how it was before the fire.....but using modern more fire resistant materials and modern building safety standards? Modernists get the updates they want only with modern building materials while traditionalists get back the cathedral as how it looked before. But the real winner would be the cathedral itself in that it would get fire resistant materials and work that meets modern building codes making it less likely for a major fire like what happened to occur again.

  • Vance L. Gilmore
    Vance L. Gilmore 2 months ago

    This is a great way to preserve what remains of the cathedral, and actually improve it dramatically by letting in so much natural light from above. Imagine fragrant roses growing there atop Notre Dame...

  • United Netherlands
    United Netherlands 3 months ago

    Only satan would use modern glass/steel architecture too rebuild something this magnificent. No surprise with the Catholic minions of satan, disgusting 🤡🔥

  • Amadís
    Amadís 3 months ago +1

    Never going to happen, this ancient European cathedral is not your toy for your disgusting and ugly postmodernist fantasies

  • ?
    ? 3 months ago +1

    And whilst they are at it, why not repaint the Mona Lisa's head as a rabbit. Same psychology.

    • Noe Berengena
      Noe Berengena 2 months ago

      Wow. That would make all the art magazines, as well as the evening news. I am sure the merchandising on that would be highly lucrative. Jeff Koons, are you listening?

  • globalmonkey
    globalmonkey 3 months ago +2

    Terrible idea for Notre Dame!

  • Harald Hoel
    Harald Hoel 4 months ago +3

    NO!!!!!!!!

  • Gr8Success
    Gr8Success 4 months ago +2

    i think its a good idea

  • ?
    ? 4 months ago +5

    The only positive side of this half-wit proposal is that they held back from proposing turning it into a trendy a shopping mall with Starbucks under the spire!

  • luemsaga1994
    luemsaga1994 5 months ago +2

    Building it back to it's original shape is architectural falacy because we do not longer live in the time when the original roof was made. Notre Dame is not original from one epoque but a palimpsest of many. Just like Le Duc's XIX century spire was, in it's time, a modern re imagination of how ideal gothic should be. (Neo gothic)
    So, why not honor the memory of the fire with XXI century adition?

    • Noe Berengena
      Noe Berengena 2 months ago +1

      Better yet, why not execute a XXII century addition?

    • Amadís
      Amadís 3 months ago +1

      The original shape before the fire, which makes the building beautiful and not a disgusting postmodernist grotesque aberration. "We" don't need to honor the memory of a catastrophe by doing another. And are you even French? because this whole "we" is very funny, you have no power to say what the French have to do with their cultural legacy

  • Oiled Up And Ready !
    Oiled Up And Ready ! 5 months ago

    J'adore 💋

  • remyposees
    remyposees 5 months ago

    i like it except may be to much green stuff like in an office

  • MarioSonic2010
    MarioSonic2010 5 months ago +2

    0:40
    It does look pretty... But I don’t think it’s needed.

  • Robert Fripp
    Robert Fripp 5 months ago +8

    It would be more respectuful to leave it as it is: destroyed.

    RIP France

  • Tim W
    Tim W 5 months ago +2

    Water leaking glass roof, oh h3ll no! I haven't seen one that hasn't leaked.

  • Liftmaster1280
    Liftmaster1280 6 months ago +1

    I like it. It’s a really pretty idea. The only thing that pisses me off, is that they would build the roof with wood. That’s a good chunk of the reason why the fire spread so easily, was because of the wood roof.

  • Gus W
    Gus W 6 months ago +1

    How fucking dare you. Take your piece of shit design andf fuck right off, philistines.

  • drabtoka 76
    drabtoka 76 6 months ago +4

    Somebody seems to have forgotten that it is a CHURCH,not an amusement park!they can build such a modern cathedral somewhere else, but not in Paris!

    • Neirea Heydensee
      Neirea Heydensee 4 months ago +1

      drabtoka 76 way not in Paris. I think you know nothing about Paris. You have many modern structures, buildings and skycrapers in Paris. Paris cannot be restricted to the historic center, where all tourists come but a very tiny part of Paris.

  • Ominous
    Ominous 6 months ago +6

    No one beats Eugène Emmanuel Violett-le-Duc's design. Rebuild it exactly like it was, and paint certain ornaments in gold.

  • Trenten P
    Trenten P 6 months ago +1

    Take a medieval cathedral and turn it into a shopping mall. When do we as a people take a step back and realize we fuck everything.

  • Robert the Sailor
    Robert the Sailor 6 months ago

    Notre *Dame Tu Cosita*

  • Se Pa
    Se Pa 6 months ago +16

    A monumental, 7-century cathedral turned to a church with a greenhouse/recreation park on the top. I'm absolutely astonished how progressive we are! They could as well open a kiosk selling hamburgers and a pub!

    • Noe Berengena
      Noe Berengena 2 months ago

      How soon could we get a mini food court, where urban hep cats can stare into their iPads and iPhones as they munch on almond croissants and drink espressos? The main thing the glass roof scheme does is create an observation deck to look over the city of Paris in all directions. Is that a good thing? Yes? No?

  • marvelfannumber1
    marvelfannumber1 6 months ago +5

    I like how the glass is made to have the same color as the original roof, and has the same silhouette/shape. I also like that le Duc's spire is faithfully reconstructed. The greenery inside however is pretty generic, something more interesting could be done there.
    Overall, I'd still vastly prefer rebuilding it as it was with modern reinforcement/fireproofing, but if it *has* to be something modern, this would be fine. It is a fine compromise. Probably the only good suggestion I've seen so far for a a new design.

  • evil22565 • 1 year ago
    evil22565 • 1 year ago 6 months ago +11

    Why not just built it back to how it was originally?

  • Robbe Nagel
    Robbe Nagel 6 months ago +42

    I have to admit, it looks really cool. But it's a huge disrespect to the French and their cultural heritage.

    • J.R. Productions
      J.R. Productions Month ago +1

      @AnniIsIn It'll be a prayer garden.

    • Minty Zaki
      Minty Zaki 2 months ago

      Who cares it looks cool

    • Escargot C'est
      Escargot C'est 6 months ago

      @AnniIsIn Most monastery of the same period had either a garden or cloister featuring a place with open sky to think to the outer space.

    • AnniIsIn
      AnniIsIn 6 months ago +3

      @Can we get 100 subs without any vids? A place of recreation and noise on top of a place of worship and quietness. Why dontcha just open up a s.c. up there?

    • Can we get 100 subs without any vids?
      Can we get 100 subs without any vids? 6 months ago +1

      Robbe Nagel why disrespect

  • Kurturmis
    Kurturmis 6 months ago +23

    while it does a nice nod to original buildings architecture for a modern design, I am still not sold on the idea because it is modernist architecture, most people want Notre Dame rebuilt how it was to restore the history that was lost.

    • Mr roy
      Mr roy Month ago

      @Vance L. Gilmore there are alot of people that dont like modern buildings the reason why these buildings get so much toerists is because they are beautiful and should stay that way

    • Vance L. Gilmore
      Vance L. Gilmore 2 months ago

      I say we should give it a transparent roof. So what about history? That got burned up. Notre Dame would be the first medieval cathedral to be restored in such a marvelous way after a devastating 🔥

  • James Gunningham
    James Gunningham 6 months ago +2

    modern architecture is crap

  • Joey Ohalloran
    Joey Ohalloran 6 months ago +6

    No the wooden roof suits the building better

  • Waltayr Dantas Filho
    Waltayr Dantas Filho 6 months ago +1

    Fire in the forest ... terrifying but renewing

  • Moo
    Moo 6 months ago +6

    Looks like a London park not a cathedral...

  • AnniIsIn
    AnniIsIn 6 months ago +13

    REEEEEEEEE IT DOES NOT NEED A GARDEN OR GLASS IT JUST NEEDS TO HAVE ITS TIMBER REPLACED

    • Gus W
      Gus W 6 months ago +2

      Pretty much, yes.

  • Phi Vince
    Phi Vince 6 months ago +7

    j'hésite encore ...mais ce genre de projet avec du verre me plairait assez et me semblerait respectueux et d'aujourd'hui ...après le coté galerie marchande cela manque encore de spiritualité !

  • Waffel Reitter
    Waffel Reitter 6 months ago +6

    It still looks Hideous Put it back the way it was before the fire.

  • Tristan Jalleh
    Tristan Jalleh 6 months ago +20

    the glass is kind of cool but the 'rooftop' garden concept reminds me of nearly every proposed redevelopment/modern apartment building iv'e seen in the last decade. it's a very nice but generic concept. In 200 hundred years they might wish we had just restored it to how it was, because anything we do to 'update' it by current modern standards with fall out of fashion in the coming decades anyway.

  • Sy Sharp
    Sy Sharp 6 months ago +3

    They should next burn down the EU parliament and replace it with something more traditional.

  • Ryan
    Ryan 6 months ago +4

    Notre-Damnnn

  • MrDelvoye
    MrDelvoye 6 months ago +8

    Glass doesn't mean modern...i dont like it

    • Waffel Reitter
      Waffel Reitter 6 months ago +1

      @MrDelvoye
      I second this Notion

    • mistaT
      mistaT 6 months ago +2

      @MrDelvoye agreed

    • MrDelvoye
      MrDelvoye 6 months ago +5

      @mistaT a simple restoration would be a good thing

    • mistaT
      mistaT 6 months ago +7

      so what if it "doesn't mean modern ", what the fuck has that got to do with restoring such a monument as the Notre Dame?

  • Howsotope
    Howsotope 6 months ago

    Guys and aliens can u join my sexy channel,🤔🙄 i need to buy a car

  • kobe navarro
    kobe navarro 6 months ago +8

    this is actually a beautiful concept

    • kobe navarro
      kobe navarro 5 months ago +1

      Chinggis Han i get that but what’s so wrong with controversy? if not every, almost every noteable piece of architecture was controversial at its time that’s how it grows and develops. buildings survive by adapting with the times. people thought gaudi was crazy as fuck but now look at how his pieces stand. i get the point you’re trying to make but i think it only further supports the unique-ness and talents of the architect.

    • Chinggis Han
      Chinggis Han 5 months ago +2

      kobe navarro
      Listen
      The best way to avoid any kind of controversy
      From any people
      Is to simply rebuild it to the way it was.
      So many bullets from the public could be dodged.
      So much controversy could be avoided.

    • kobe navarro
      kobe navarro 6 months ago +1

      Chinggis Han i don’t think it was going for a park but even just a more sustainable design for a building as large as it is. i think being a public building that brings a lot of attraction to it anyways it’ll be nice to have a space for tourists that can be separate from the church’s masses

    • AnniIsIn
      AnniIsIn 6 months ago +2

      @Chinggis Han agreed. No need for a place to 'chill'.

    • Chinggis Han
      Chinggis Han 6 months ago +3

      Yea but
      Even as a non catholic
      This is a place of worship not a park.
      If I imagine the golden temple in Amritsar being destroyed and then being rebuilt as some sorta recreational park.
      Many would be outraged.

  • AnarchoArchitect
    AnarchoArchitect 6 months ago +41

    This is the first one they've come up with that wasn't a modern-art disaster.

    • Chinggis Han
      Chinggis Han 6 months ago +8

      A park on a cathedral?
      A place of recreation/noise on top of a quiet place of worship?
      Not a good idea.